Messages

You know, this reminds me of the controversy of Alice Miller's son Martin, a psychotherapist in Switzerland re his book about his mother (https://www.outofthestorm.website/guest-bloggers/2019/4/28/how-victims-become-perpetrators-passing-war-trauma-on-to-your-own-children). The book is titled "The True Drama of the Gifted Child" and is about his abuse at the hands of his mother. When he published it he received both criticism because his mother was so beloved for her work in child trauma and no-one could quite believe what he was saying, and complements for sharing his truth about her.

I had a difficult time knowing quite what to think and feel myself until I came to see what Martin himself see's about his mother. That is, she was never quite able to deal with the trauma of the war and ended up passing it on, but that her work is still so very important because she had a strong intuitive and intellectual grasp about childhood trauma. It made me think that she is actually a good example of just how hard it is for anyone to deal with trauma, in her case so much so she pushed it down, intellectualized about it, only to have it seep out on her children.

I feel the same way about Gabor Mate, that is, I still see a lot of value in what he has contributed to the field even after reading her article, but am grateful that the author raised what are some serious issues. It's problematic to put people on a pedestal because we make ourselves vulnerable in doing so. I don't need a hero, but I do need professionals to have a strong moral and ethical compass so I can trust them. If he is indeed drifting away from the rigour and solid ethics needed in healthcare, I want to know that.

Asdis, these are just my thoughts of course but I remembered feeling similarly some time back in recovery and thought I'd share about what helped me. I remember I started to see a lot of books and articles about being self-compassionate as I was working really hard on recovering and that sort of grabbed me for some reason. I took what I was reading to heart and for me that meant slowing down and not doing so much, about trying less hard rather than more hard, and of being less perfectionistic and accepting that I am human. So many of us have such a bossy Inner Critic that we don't even think to tell it to shush, to question what it is telling us, and to move toward a more compassionate loving self that the IC blots out.

I don't know if this will resonate with you but I hope some of it does and you can step outside that endless loop. 

Tks for posting this BB     

I continue to be amazed that there are now "Super" conferences about trauma. I remember when I started this forum back in 2014, there were very few conferences, books, articles, etc.  Now it's a regular smorgasbord - yay!

Hi and a warm welcome to Out of the Storm Shosh 

Like The Big Blue I too am glad you are choosing to be honest about needing to work at recovery on an ongoing basis. It took a long time for me to admit that here because I didn't want anyone to be discouraged. Eventually I decided that it was my truth and one I needed to express and that others would need to decide for themselves what is true for them.

Hope you find being here helpful 

 

Welcome to Out of the Storm Highimpedance  So sorry for all that you have been through and are dealing with at present. I'm always happy when survivors manage to find their way here and begin to feel the relief of not being so alone anymore.

I absolutely love the term "post-traumatic joy" SO      There is nothing quite so wonderful than feeling that connection and understanding with other survivors that can bring about a sense of belonging and joy.  Pass the champagne please 

Just my two cents BB, but CBT bothers many of us because often we didn't feel like (or were made to feel like) we were "getting it right" much as you experienced. A lot of us find CBT can be helpful for some things (e.g., I got over my fear of flying and reduced my social anxiety), but it is limited (IMO) when it comes to those deep core wounds we suffered and the symptoms they gave rise to because they are so primal/emotional in nature. They are wounds you can't think your way out of, they need to be addressed in a relational context with a T who feels safe and trustworthy just as you suggested.

Getting over a fear of flying is just not the same as the fear of ever being in a position where I have no power or control, the fear of being so vulnerable, and the necessity of doing what I have to to survive. There is every reason to continue to fear that (because I have been through it), and to do what I can to never ever feel that way again, unless and until I have someone I can connect with and who will walk through those feelings with me. 

If you go to Pete Walker's site he talks about why he takes a relational approach as well as what a T needs to be for CPTSD clients. Both felt right to me since I read his book back in 2014 and still do. See https://pete-walker.com/pdf/relationalHealingComplexPTSD.pdf.

Good luck with your upcoming therapy appointment, I hope you are able to get across why it was not helpful when your T tried to reason you out of a feeling of a loss of safety.

Unfortunately TB, as we are an international site we aren't able to pass along much in the way of info about individual T's. We do have databases where you can search for a T who specializes in one thing or another here - https://www.cptsd.org/forum/index.php?topic=881.0. If you do find T's in your area there is info about how much they charge or whether they will use a sliding scale based on your income.

The other thing that works well is simply to use Google to search for your location.

Good luck!

I'm so sorry to hear this BB. Just my thoughts here but the fact that you know you have borrowed regulation to me sounds like you know what is the problem and by facing it and the pain and fear you are on the road out the other side.

I say from experience that some of my most painful moments came from seeing clearly what I had lost in my life, what I could not depend upon, and what I had to do to carry on. Looking at that led to looking at myself clearly, with compassion and shushing the negative voices. Slowly I came to realize I could depend on myself. Fear and pain became a feeling of freedom and trust in myself, however wobbly at first.

I hope this is helpful     

Hey Teddy Bear, not to worry about asking for feedback about experiences of psychosis and neuroleptics. As I mentioned in my response to another of your posts, psychosis can be comorbid with CPTSD, so it makes sense to ask about it here.

I'm afraid I haven't had any instances of psychosis, but I just want to let you know it's OK to ask.

Hi Teddy Bear and a warm welcome to Out of the Storm 

From what I've read CPTSD and psychosis often overlap (e.g., https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11496218/) although it's likely not all healthcare professionals know this. There is a tendency to discount childhood trauma, as though we should have just gotten over it, not realizing it's lasting impact.

I hope you're able to find a therapist who does understand this as it goes a long way to have validation and focused treatment.   

[Moving On After Trauma: A Guide for Survivors, Family and Friends]

Here's a book you might find useful EB. I haven't read it but it sounds good and got a 4.6/5 rating on GoodReads:

Moving On After Trauma: A Guide for Survivors, Family and Friends by Michael J. Scott

The effects of extreme trauma can continue to be emotionally devastating. Moving On After Trauma offers hope, providing survivors, family members and friends with a roadmap for managing emotional, relationship, physical and legal obstacles to recovery. Dr Scott details examples of the strategies used by twenty characters who have recovered and the survivor (with or without the help of a family member, friend or counsellor) is encouraged to identify with one or more of them and follow in their footsteps.

Hi and a warm welcome to Out of the Storm Ray 

Lots of great feedback for you and connection above which is part of what helps many survivors who come here. Members just get it so it feels safe and comforting.

I am one for whom healing/recovery means now having fewer and less intense triggers, knowing what my triggers are and what to do, being kind and compassionate with myself, shushing my Inner Critic, and connecting with others. I have looked straight on at some of the really painful things in my life (like your family's betrayal) and have let go of the need for my family to change, be the people I deserved/needed. They just can't/won't and chasing that is an exercise in futility and pain. Once I realized that, I let go of them and the wish/hope I'd been clinging to.  It was very painful but also freeing and over time I was less impacted by it, mainly because other things opened up in my life.

I don't know if this will help, but I hope so.    

I think NK and LBTV have captured what it is Saluki. I have found that I spiral less and less as I am able most times to interrupt a downward slide or spiral. Over Christmas I was triggered by something and could feel myself begin to spiral (everything adding up to a worsening EF), but I knew what to do and sure enough I was fine once I took action to stop the spiral. For me that involved talking with my H, going out with friends and my son who was here for Christmas. In the past I might have cancelled going out and stayed in my bedroom until it passed. So, for me connection with others is one very powerful tool.  It can be other things depending on the survivor though. 

Good grief Ran, a 2 year wait for therapy, that's completely unacceptable! I don't know about where you live but here in Canada many therapists treat according to a sliding scale, what you can reasonably pay. It might be something to check.

Good to hear you have a friend who is trying to help you bring out your inner child. That's what I worked on first and it made such a difference that young me had some fun and began to trust adult me to look out for her.

Hope you're able to get some therapy earlier than 2 years and in the meantime, let your inner child have some fun. It's a balm to the soul or so I found.